Thread: Edgeville hub

Can you show an overview of the entire region? It looks cluttered as fuck. Only thing I commend you on is not doing the traditional (having multiple npcs under one roof as shops)

Originally Posted by Melvin

Can you show an overview of the entire region? It looks cluttered as fuck. Only thing I commend you on is not doing the traditional (having multiple npcs under one roof as shops)

Agreed. One thing I would like to suggest is to look at some other cities in Runescape/the spacing between the houses/buildings. I also think you have too many houses that are higher than just 1 height level.



Regarding the quarry, id recommend rotating those 3 iron rocks 180 degrees so peeps dont have to walk as far to get to the sweet 3 rock spot..

There's 5 houses with upstairs but only 3 which the player would normally go on.
One being if the player is doing agility, other one if they want to talk with the smith and the third if they want to start a quest (that ladder is also pointless from a certain point in the quest.)

I wanted it to be cramped btw

There's climbing rocks in the quarry behind the 3 rocks, and there's also a mineshaft for higher level mining (custom motherlode mine) which I forgot to showcase, the entrance is visible from the quarry pic

Not bad but looks cluttered as hell.

Originally Posted by Linus

Thanks. Yeah its cluttered. I suggest removing the building in the middle and making the town centre bigger. Also remove the 3 buildings to the left of the stalls. Then it sort of turns into rimmington. (but still more building populated). Now its giving ape atoll vibes and its horrible for navigation. You'd have to give players a guide just to get around the home area.

Note: I probably would've never gone with edgeville to begin as a base. As a show off and seeing edgeville, regardless of how much work put into it is like... ugh again. You get what im saying? Not being rude but you should've really probably made like an entire mainland on an island or a custom city that doesnt involve everything being a minimap click away in radius.

it looks abit of a cluster-fuck if i'm honest

Originally Posted by Melvin

Thanks. Yeah its cluttered. I suggest removing the building in the middle and making the town centre bigger. Also remove the 3 buildings to the left of the stalls. Then it sort of turns into rimmington. (but still more building populated). Now its giving ape atoll vibes and its horrible for navigation. You'd have to give players a guide just to get around the home area.

Note: I probably would've never gone with edgeville to begin as a base. As a show off and seeing edgeville, regardless of how much work put into it is like... ugh again. You get what im saying? Not being rude but you should've really probably made like an entire mainland on an island or a custom city that doesnt involve everything being a minimap click away in radius.

I was trying to make it more rpg oriented, the other cities would not have been accessible, so this would stand as the only "town"
I like your idea of clearing the middle
Was supposed to be only edgeville and north including the bosses. things got in the way and I sort of lost interest

edit
also while making this map I was just making friends with the map editor, for the lack of better judgement I decided to cram it all in one chunk. If I were to remake this today I'd definatively space it out more, maybe even use the wilderness to kind of build in some ruined part of town. >.>